Document No. 7 — Engineering Decision-Making, Risk Management, and Uncertainty
Principles of This Document
Principle 1 — Complete Information Is Not a Prerequisite for Getting Started
The acceptable level of information must be assessed, along with the value of obtaining additional information relative to its cost and the time required.
Principle 2 — Recognizing Limitations Is Part of Engineering
When a gap in expertise exists, external specialists, consultants, specialized companies, or scientific collaborations should be engaged.
Principle 3 — Project Value Is Not Limited to Direct Profit
Strategic value, reputation, knowledge, new customers, and new markets also contribute to project evaluation.
Principle 4 — A Financial Contingency Margin Must Be Considered in Strategic Projects
Under this document's framework, the estimated cost ceiling is set at 80% of the total project value, with 20% allocated to risks and contingencies.
Principle 5 — Professional Commitment Continues After Project Acceptance
Any cost increase must be documented and presented to the customer for resolution. A cost increase alone must not lead to simply withdrawing from the commitment.
Principle 6 — Professional Reputation Is More Important Than the Profit from a Single Project
A project loss can be recovered, but damage to reputation can have long-term consequences.
Principle 7 — Estimation Errors Must Lead to System Improvement
Every error must be investigated to identify its cause and documented to improve future estimates.
Principle 8 — An Understood Failure Is More Controllable Than an Unknown One
Knowing the cause and mechanism of a failure is itself an engineering achievement.
Principle 9 — Unresolved Problems Must Remain Active
If the cause has been identified but reliable prevention is not available, the case must remain open and pending, rather than simply being archived.
Principle 10 — Knowledge Related to Pending Problems Must Be Preserved
Data, samples, analyses, rejected hypotheses, causes, and evidence must be retained until a solution is found.
Principle ۱۱ — Learning Must Lead to Improvements in Future Decisions
The cycle of decision, implementation, outcome, analysis, documentation, learning, and system improvement must be repeated.